Research
My research addresses the architectural and urban history of modernism across the Americas with a focus on technology, law, geopolitics, labor, Indigeneity, and racial capitalism.
Raymond Loewy’s Desert House by Clark & Frey, 1947. South view onto Agua Caliente Reservation land. Photograph by Julius Shulman. # J. Paul Getty Trust. Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles (2004.R.10).
Book publications
Council Chairwoman Eileen Miguel and developer Sam Banowit outside Palm Springs Spa Hotel entrance colonnade. Cover, “Palm Springs Spa Hotel and Mineral Springs: First Anniversary,” c.1964. Courtesy of Agua Caliente Cultural Museum.
Inland Empire: Settler Colonialism, Modern Architecture, and the Rise of American Hegemony
By Manuel Shvartzberg Carrió
Forthcoming from Duke University Press
Inland Empire: Settler Colonialism, Modern Architecture, and the Rise of American Hegemony, explores how modernist architecture and urban design structured the settler-colonial project and rationalized liberal ideas of legal order in the twentieth century. Focusing on Palm Springs’s settlement upon the Agua Caliente Reservation and the surrounding Colorado and Mojave deserts, it shows how architecture became a fundamental technology for governing Empire through Indigenous land and migrant labor, while also fundamentally mediating the Agua Caliente’s own efforts toward self-determination. The book has been supported by a publication grant from the Graham Foundation and a Getty Research Institute Fellowship.
Inland Empire shows that the canonical discourse on midcentury modern American architecture cannot be disentangled from the history of settler-colonization and its resistance by Indigenous nations. Palm Springs in Southern California offers a particularly illustrative case study of this dynamic: as a favorite holiday resort for prominent artists, capitalists and politicians, it was both conceived and constructed as a model settler-colonial city. From early colonial structures to midcentury estates, modernist architects like Lloyd Wright, Richard Neutra, Albert Frey, and William Krisel, working for builders, speculators, and politicians, enshrined and instrumentalized the Agua Caliente’s underdevelopment for settler profit and power. Their technological innovations in environmental design, construction, and the management of labor developed sophisticated new ways to fragment and alienate Indigenous land and sovereignty. At the urban and regional scale, their projects segregated the new desert leisure economy from the Inland Empire’s sprawling military and agricultural infrastructures, redefining Manifest Destiny for a post-industrial world. Design, I argue, offered particular ways of managing Indigenous resistance by reinforcing the underlying logics of a rising American hegemony: economic and logistical growth via environmental extraction, racialized displacement, and selective assimilation into markets and civil society.
These colonization efforts, however, were resisted by Agua Caliente political leaders, from Francisco Patencio to Vyola Olinger, who deployed various unorthodox design tactics against discriminatory urban policies, as well as the many anonymous Indigenous and other racialized peoples who lived on the Reservation. I trace their formal and informal architectures of resistance as a kind of decolonial modernity, with consequences for how we should understand architecture as a discipline that produces and enforces legal orders.
The Region: Spatial Histories of a Naturalized Concept
Edited by Ayala Levin and Manuel Shvartzberg Carrió
Forthcoming from Aggregate Architectural History Collaborative (online volume)
This edited volume critically unpacks the idea of the “region” that underlies regionalism in architectural discourse. Instead of thinking of the region as a spatial-cultural given, the authors interrogate its historical construction as a technique of governance and as a mode of coloniality, asking how and why the region came to architectural prominence in conjunction with the formation of urban planning.
Often collapsed into a geographic category, the region crystalized processes of economic and racial formation within the constitution of the nation state in the nineteenth century. But by the end of the century, it grew an independent meaning, becoming a flexible territorial unit that could attach itself to political and administrative boundaries at will. This ambiguity holds still true today, with the region at times traversing international borders to designate geo-strategic economic or military alliances, or in other cases, broadening constellations of the “local” – a vehicle for claim-making and self-determination against the state.
The region’s capaciousness and spatio-temporal elasticity is examined in this volume, showing how it has been mobilized to advance different political ends. The essays cover such disparate geographies and regimes including turn of the century Germany, American archeology in the Middle East in the 1920s, the 1930s Soviet Union, interwar France, colonial and postcolonial India, and Colombia and Northern Canada in the postwar periods. The essays illustrate the region’s expansive reach as an epistemic construct, offering valuable analyses of the intersections between architectural history and the workings of territory.
The Politics of Parametricism: Digital Technologies in Architecture
Edited by Matthew Poole and Manuel Shvartzberg Carrió
Bloomsbury Academic, 2015
'Parametricism' has been heralded as a new avant-garde in the industries of architecture, urban design, and industrial design, regarded by many as the next grand style in the history of architecture, heir to postmodernism and deconstruction. From buildings to cities, the built environment is increasingly addressed, designed and constructed using digital software based on parametric scripting platforms which claim to be able to process complex physical and social modelling alike.
As more and more digital tools are developed into an apparently infinite repertoire of socio-technical functions, critical questions concerning these cultural and technological shifts are often eclipsed by the seductive aesthetic and the alluring futuristic imaginary that parametric design tools and their architectural products and discourses represent.
The Politics of Parametricism addresses these issues, offering a collection of new essays written by leading international thinkers in the fields of digital design, architecture, theory and technology. Exploring the social, political, ethical and philosophical issues at stake in the history, practice and processes of parametric architecture and urbanism, each chapter provides different vantage points to interrogate the challenges and opportunities presented by this latest mode of technological production.
With essays by:
Phil Bernstein, Benjamin Bratton, Christina Cogdell, Teddy Cruz, Peggy Deamer, Andrés Jaque, Laura Kurgan and Dan Taeyoung, Neil Leach, Reinhold Martin, Matthew Poole, Peg Rawes, Patrik Schumacher, and Manuel Shvartzberg Carrió.
Asymmetric Labors: The Economy of Architecture in Theory and Practice
Edited by Aaron Cayer, Peggy Deamer, Sben Korsh, Eric Peterson, and Manuel Shvartzberg Carrió
The Architecture Lobby, 2016
With contributions from over fifty architectural historians, theorists, students, writers, and practitioners from across the globe, the texts in this volume provide a slice through the uneven terrain of values and unequal labor practices of historical and theoretical architectural work. The booklet is intended to spark a conversation about what the value of such labor is, both within the discipline and profession of architecture, and how it impacts and is impacted by the discursive and material production of the built environment.
With essays by:
Felipe Aravena, Pier Vittorio Aureli, Daniel A. Barber, Chris Barker, Kadambari Baxi, Nick Beech, Joaquin Díez Canedo, Jordan Carver, Aaron Cayer, Dariel Cobb, Kieran Connolly, Joe Crowdy, Tobias Danielmeier, Peggy Deamer, Laura Diamond Dixit, Kirti Durelle, Eva Hagberg Fisher, Gary Fox, Frabrizio Gallanti, Curt Gambetta, Anna Goodman, James Graham, Gevork Hartoonian, Andrew Herscher, Mark Jarzombek, Tahl Kaminer, Hanan Kataw, Anne Kockelkorn, Sben Korsh, Christos Kritkos, Nadir Lahiji, James Longfield, Yasser Megahed, Jacob Moore, Joan Ockman, Daniel Fernández Pascual, Joanne Preston, Eric Peterson, Peg Rawes, Eric Wycoff Rogers, Andreas Rumpfhuber, Susanne Schindler, Jack Self, Adam Sharr, Manuel Shvartzberg Carrió, Brent Sturlaugson, Meredith TenHoor, Stefano Tornieri, Alessandro Toti, Norihiko Tsuneishi, Tijana Vujosevic, Mabel O. Wilson, Yang Yang.
Recent articles and book chapters
Architectural Theory Review, 2023
How should we do the history of US midcentury modernist architecture—a period marked by intense campaigns of Native American dispossession in the face of organised Indigenous resistance?The spatial development of the Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians’ ancestral lands in Palm Springs, California, offers an illustrative case study for these intersections; a history of colonial settlement both enabled and constrained as much by canonical architects like Albert Frey and Richard Neutra as by the Agua Caliente’s own highly influential political activism. This history challenges the perfect model of nested state jurisdiction—seamlessly connecting territory and expertise—to show a tangle of jurisdictional relations of various degrees and kinds of opacity,marked and mediated by architecture. This article explores these entanglements as the effects of “jurisdictional technics,” or how architecture organised relations of authority among and between competing regimes of order.
Designing Terra Nullius: Midcentury Modernism and the Governance of Settler-Colonial Leisure
Book chapter in Coastal Architectures and Politics of Tourism: Leisurescapes in the Global Sunbelt, edited by Panayiota Pyla, Sibel Bozdogan, Petros Phokaides, Routledge, 2022
This chapter considers the ways in which midcentury modernism configured Southern California’s leisurescape by implicitly articulating and reproducing terra nullius as a colonial mode of territorial management. The relation between the Reservation of the Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians and the modern development of Palm Springs, California, is historicized in connection with the US’s legal-institutional colonial administration and corresponding disciplinary discourses of modern architecture. Rather than being a legal fiction or a past historical event, terra nullius is shown to be spatially-produced through the architecturally-mediated encounter of different settler-colonial legacies and capitalist modes of surplus extraction—a process that continues today. This architectural-territorial condition reduces Native sovereignty via two modes of biopolitical management: racialization and regionalization. Two projects in the Agua Caliente Reservation/city of Palm Springs—Lloyd Wright’s Oasis Hotel (1925) and William Cody’s Palm Springs Spa (1960)—show how architecture’s articulation of terra nullius since the nineteenth century conditioned this territory as a postwar leisurescape.
Infrastructures of Dependency: U.S. Steel’s Architectural Assemblages on Indigenous Lands
Book chapter in Architecture in Development: Systems and the Emergence of the Global South, edited by Arindam Dutta, Ateya Khorakiwala, Ayala Levin, Fabiola López-Durán, Ijlal Muzaffar (Architecture Collaborative), Routledge, 2022
This chapter examines the relations between Native American, Latin American, and liberal theories of economic development through a critical reading of two projects spearheaded by US Steel in the early post-World War II period: a series of prefabricated steel houses for Palm Springs, California, and the iron-ore mining settlement that would become Ciudad Guayana, in Venezuela. The projects illustrate how architectural expertise structured US Steel’s postwar operations—from production and consumption, to resource extraction and distribution—as a fungible infrastructural system critical to the US’s bid for hegemony in the Cold War. However, the projects were located on Indigenous lands, posing questions of Native sovereignty, ecological destruction, and racialized segregation often neglected by development theories. The architects and planners designing and rationalizing these projects displaced these issues through an architectural discourse on regionalism that reworked colonial architectural devices—namely, the grid and the patio—to enact a “transition” from rural to urban life, and from non-capitalist societies to capitalist modernity.
Designing Decolonization? Architecture and Indigenous Development
Book chapter in The Routledge Handbook of Indigenous Development, edited by Nancy Postero, Irma Alicia Velasquez Nimatuj, and John Andrew McNeish, London: Routledge Handbook series, 2022
Over the past few years, there have been growing calls to “decolonize” architecture around the world. This chapter surveys what these calls have entailed, particularly from within North American architecture, and from the perspective of Indigenous architects who are redefining the role architecture might play for a critical discourse of Indigenous development. What emerges from this brief overview is not a coherent theory of contemporary Native American architecture or a set of prescriptions for “good” Indigenous development, but a set of long-enduring colonial fault lines and conflicts immanent to the relation between modern design, development, and Indigeneity. New approaches to contemporary Indigenous architecture wrestle with these fault lines, at points challenging core tenets of architecture as a modern profession, as well as offering perspectives on what Indigenous architectural development can be, and how dramatically it might – and in many ways already is – altering the constitution of architecture as a discipline across the world.
The Red Deal: Decolonizing Climate Action
Article co-authored with Danika Cooper, Architectural Design 92, no. 1 (2022): 78–85. Special issue on the Green New Deal, guest edited by Jose Alfredo Ramirez.
Decolonisation or extinction. This is the imperative posed by The Red Nation, a collective of Native American activists and scholars who put forth a policy platform that radicalises the ambitions of the Green New Deal. Their "Red Deal" articulates a vision and strategy for how Indigeneity can and should be at the centre of projects addressing climate action; not as "a counterprogram to the GND, but rather going beyond it. It is 'red' because it prioritizes Indigenous liberation and a revolutionary left position." Successful climate action depends on a radical shift away from the current neoliberal paradigm in favour of resilient, adaptive and non-patriarchal structures. Yet a climate-adaptive future must also account for both the history of colonialism and its ongoing practices. Considering that Indigenous peoples account for 5 per cent of the global population but protect 80 per cent of all biodiversity, the survival of planetary life is contingent upon their continued caretaking of their lands. As such, Indigenous land ‘rematriation’ – the act of returning stolen Indigenous lands, culture, knowledge and resources – is critical to the articulation of any climate action plan.
Decolonial Platform Urbanism
Book chapter in Platform Urbanism and Its Discontents, Peter Moertenboeck and Helge Mooshammer, eds. Rotterdam: Nai010 Publishers, 2021
How should we think of corporate capitalism in terms of decolonisation, platforms and architecture? The history of U.S. hegemonic representations of state-capital flows offers a clue. Take, for example, a diagram for the total rationalisation of the architecture and construction industries from 1943, articulating the modernist dream of total socio-logistical integration, titled “The Architectural Center” (Fig.1). The early cyberneticism implied by the feedback loops between “Industry,” “Architects & Engineering in Private Practice,” “Architectural and Technical Schools,” “Public Relations,” and “Research Laboratories,” all magically coordinated by a new “Architectural Center,” offers a cautionary tale. As we grapple with the existential need to address multiple overlapping systemic crises – from climate change to a pandemic, from racism to resurgent fascism – the desire for a singular technological fix is palpable and understandable. Enter “Platform Urbanism.” What could be more enticing than the promise of a universal technological solution?
Palm Springs and the Nomos of Modernity: Prefabricated Steel Houses, Automation, and Settler Colonialism in Postwar America, 1943–1968
Book chapter in in Productive Universals—Specific Situations: Critical Engagements in Art, Architecture and Urbanism, edited by Anne Kockelkorn & Nina Zschocke, Berlin: Sternberg Press, 2019